Penthouse Suites in NYC: What the Word Means, and What We'd Book Instead

Quick answer

A penthouse suite in NYC has no standard definition: hotels use the word for their largest top-floor suite, and what most people are actually paying for is the private outdoor space. We don't call anything here a penthouse. What we do have is three suites with their own private terrace, from an 800 sq ft two bedroom up to an 1,100 sq ft three bedroom, plus a 1,200 sq ft three bedroom that sleeps eight. Every one of them has a full kitchen, and our rooftop terrace is open to everyone staying with us, terrace suite or not.

Our rooftop terrace with benches and planting, open to every guest.
Our rooftop terrace, open to everyone staying with us.

What a penthouse suite actually means in New York

There's no standard definition, which is the first thing worth knowing. "Penthouse" isn't a regulated category the way a room's square footage or bed count is. In practice a hotel uses it for its largest suite on its highest floor, and the price reflects the name as much as the room. When you read the fine print, the thing that usually justifies the number is private outdoor space, not the floor.

So it's worth separating the two. Do you want to be high up, or do you want a door that opens onto your own terrace? They're different purchases, and in Lower Manhattan they often cost very different amounts.

We don't call anything here a penthouse

We'd rather tell you the square footage. Our largest apartments run from 800 up to 1,200 sq ft, and the names are plain: the Grand 2 Bedroom with Massive Private Terrace is 1,000 sq ft, the Signature 3 Bedroom with Private Terrace is 1,100 sq ft, the Deluxe 2 Bedroom with Private Terrace is 800 sq ft, and the Luxury 3 Bedroom Apartment, our biggest floor plan, is 1,200 sq ft and sleeps up to eight.

If you want a comparison point: our smallest studio is 340 sq ft. So the three bedroom is roughly three and a half studios with one kitchen.

The terrace is the part worth paying for

Outdoor space is the rarest thing in a Manhattan room, and it's the part of a penthouse people actually remember. Three of our apartments have their own terrace. Two of them, the Signature 3 Bedroom with Private Terrace and the Deluxe 2 Bedroom with Private Terrace, are on the 3rd floor, right next to each other, which is useful to know if you're travelling as two families and want to be neighbours.

Third floor, not fifteenth. That's the honest trade. You're not getting a skyline panorama from a terrace at that height in the Financial District, where the buildings around you are tall and close. You're getting somewhere to eat breakfast outside, let kids run off some energy before a museum, or sit with a drink after a long day of walking. For most stays that's the part you use.

If height is what you're after

We have a King Suite on every floor from 2 through 15, so a high floor is something you can ask us about rather than something you have to buy a suite tier to get. The Presidential King Suite is 720 sq ft with a king bed and a queen sofa bed, sleeping four. The Grand King Suite is 492 sq ft. Neither has a private terrace, and neither is a penthouse. They're large one-bedroom apartments with a kitchen and a dining table.

One more thing on height: we can't promise a specific floor at booking. Tell us what you'd like and we'll do what we can closer to your arrival.

What you get in any of them

The kitchen is the reason people book us over a room with a kettle. Every suite has a fully equipped kitchen: refrigerator, stovetop, dishwasher, microwave and convection oven, toaster, drip coffee maker, cookware, dishes, glassware, utensils and a knife set. We leave coffee and tea for you.

The rest, room by room: Frette linens, a dedicated workspace, a hair dryer in every bathroom, and showers throughout. We don't have bathtubs anywhere in the building, so if that's a dealbreaker it's better to know now than at check-in.

The parts of the building everyone gets

The rooftop terrace is open to all of our guests, with lounge chairs up there, so you don't need a terrace suite to sit outside. Our fitness center and the guest lounge are both on the lower level, and the lounge is where people wait when they land early and their suite isn't ready yet. The laundry room is free to use and we provide the detergent pods.

Worth saying plainly: we don't do daily housekeeping. If you want your apartment cleaned mid-stay we'll arrange it for $100. That's the apartment trade, and most people staying more than three nights prefer it.

So what would we book?

If there are four of you and you want outdoor space, the Deluxe 2 Bedroom with Private Terrace at 800 sq ft. If there are six to eight of you, the Luxury 3 Bedroom at 1,200 sq ft, and use the rooftop for the outdoor part. If it's two of you and the word penthouse was mostly about space and a good kitchen, the Presidential King Suite at 720 sq ft does that for a lot less than the word costs elsewhere.

We're at 17 John Street, a short walk from Fulton Street Station, which is nine subway lines in one entrance. Wall Street is a couple of blocks south. The Financial District goes quiet on weekends, which is either the reason you'll love staying here or the reason you won't.

Common questions

Do you have a penthouse suite?

No. We don't use the word for any of our apartments. Our largest floor plan is the Luxury 3 Bedroom Apartment at 1,200 sq ft, sleeping up to eight, and our largest with private outdoor space is the Signature 3 Bedroom with Private Terrace at 1,100 sq ft.

Which suites have a private terrace?

Three: the Grand 2 Bedroom with Massive Private Terrace (1,000 sq ft), the Signature 3 Bedroom with Private Terrace (1,100 sq ft), and the Deluxe 2 Bedroom with Private Terrace (800 sq ft). The Signature 3 Bedroom and the Deluxe 2 Bedroom terrace suites are both on the 3rd floor, next to each other.

Can I use the rooftop if my apartment doesn't have a terrace?

Yes. The rooftop terrace is open to every guest staying with us, and there are lounge chairs up there.

Can I request a high floor?

You can ask, and we'll do our best closer to your arrival, but we can't guarantee a floor. We do have a King Suite on every floor from 2 through 15.

Do the larger suites have bathtubs?

No. None of our apartments have a bathtub. Every bathroom has a shower.

Book your stay at 17John Hotel