Connecting Rooms in NYC: Why They're Hard to Get, and What to Book Instead

Quick answer

Connecting rooms in NYC are hard to confirm because almost no hotel guarantees them at booking; they're assigned on the day. We don't have connecting rooms at all. What we have instead is two and three bedroom apartments, from a 750 sq ft two bedroom sleeping four up to a 1,200 sq ft three bedroom sleeping eight, each with its own kitchen, so the kids get a door that closes and you get one reservation instead of two. If you'd rather book separate apartments, we'll try to put you on the same floor closer to your arrival.

An open plan apartment kitchen with a marble table and chairs.
One kitchen, one dining table, two bedrooms with doors.

Why connecting rooms are hard to get in New York

Because almost nobody guarantees them. Connecting rooms are a specific pair of rooms with a door between them, and there are only ever a handful in a building. Hotels take the request, then assign on the day depending on who checked out and what needed maintenance. You find out at the front desk, with three tired children and a stack of bags, which is the worst possible moment to learn the answer is no.

That's not a New York problem specifically, but the city makes it sharper, because rooms here are small enough that two non-connecting rooms means genuinely splitting your family across a corridor.

We don't have connecting rooms. Here's what we do instead

No connecting rooms at all, so we'll never take a request we can't honour. What we have is apartments with more than one bedroom, which is the thing people actually want when they search for connecting rooms: a door the kids can close, a room you can sit up in after they're asleep, and one bill.

Apartment Size Sleeps
Classic 2 Bedroom 750 sq ft up to 4
Deluxe 2 Bedroom 800 sq ft up to 6
Grand 2 Bedroom with Massive Private Terrace 1,000 sq ft up to 4
Superior 2 Bedroom 1,100 sq ft up to 6
Signature 3 Bedroom 1,100 sq ft up to 6
Luxury 3 Bedroom 1,200 sq ft up to 8

Every one of them has a fully equipped kitchen: refrigerator, stovetop, dishwasher, microwave and convection oven, toaster, coffee maker, cookware, dishes and a knife set. With a family that matters more than it sounds. Breakfast happens at your own table, and the 6am cereal eater doesn't have to be dressed and taken downstairs.

We sell the apartment, not the beds

We don't charge per guest. You're booking the apartment, and the occupancy for each one is what it is, so four people in a 750 sq ft two bedroom costs the same as two. If your numbers change after you've booked, we can add people to an existing reservation as long as everyone knows which apartment they're in and it stays within the occupancy.

Overnight visitors are fine too, as long as the visitor is with the registered guest and added to the reservation in advance. There's no extra fee for that. What we can't do is unregistered people staying over.

If you'd rather have two separate apartments

Some groups want two front doors rather than one apartment, usually two couples or grandparents travelling with a young family. You can book two apartments together, and we'll do our best to put them on the same floor. We say "do our best" because we assign closer to check-in, when we know what's actually free. We'd rather tell you that now than promise it in March for a trip in July.

One useful detail: two of our terrace apartments, the Signature 3 Bedroom with Private Terrace and the Deluxe 2 Bedroom with Private Terrace, sit next to each other on the 3rd floor. If being neighbours is the whole point, that pair is the closest thing we have to connecting rooms.

Booking several apartments at once

For bigger groups, roughly eight to ten apartments or parties of eighteen and up, don't do it through the booking page one at a time. Email reservations@17john.com or call (516) 570-8762 and our reservations team will bring in the sales side, who handle availability, group rates and keeping the booking together.

What the building gives a family

The laundry room is free and the detergent pods are included, which is the single most useful thing on a trip with small children. The guest lounge on the lower level is where people land when they arrive before their apartment is ready, and it has a big sofa and a TV, so it buys you an hour. Our fitness center is on the same level. The rooftop terrace is open to everyone staying with us, with lounge chairs, and it's a good place to let people burn off an hour before dinner.

Two honest notes. We don't clean daily, so on a week-long stay you're living in it the way you'd live in an apartment; a mid-stay clean is $100 if you'd like one. And none of our bathrooms have a tub, only showers, which is worth knowing if you're travelling with a toddler.

Where this puts you

17 John Street, in the Financial District. Fulton Street Station is a short walk and puts nine subway lines under one roof, which is the difference between one train to the Museum of Natural History and a change with a stroller. The neighbourhood is quiet on weekends, and Battery Park, the 9/11 Memorial and the Brooklyn Bridge are all walkable from the front door.

Common questions

Do you have connecting rooms?

No. We don't have any connecting rooms. For larger parties we have two and three bedroom apartments instead, from 750 sq ft up to 1,200 sq ft.

Can we book two apartments next to each other?

You can book them together, and we'll do our best to put you on the same floor closer to your check-in date. We can't guarantee it at the time of booking because we assign apartments nearer the day.

Do you charge extra per person?

No. We sell the apartment, not the bed, so the price is the same whether you fill the occupancy or not. Just make sure the number of guests stays within what the apartment sleeps.

What's the largest apartment you have?

The Luxury 3 Bedroom Apartment, 1,200 sq ft, sleeping up to eight. The Signature 3 Bedroom is 1,100 sq ft and sleeps up to six.

How do we book eight or more apartments?

Email reservations@17john.com or call (516) 570-8762. Our reservations team will connect you with the sales team for availability, group rates and coordinating the booking.

Book your stay at 17John Hotel